top of page

Our Story

In 1996, Kristin Sailor was expecting her second baby, a sister for her son Johnny. The little family was just squeaking by as it was. She began baking specialty muffins from her home selling them wholesale to coffee houses, delis & gas stations in Youngstown & Pittsburgh. The success of this led to her partnering with her mom, Margaret Collins. In 1999, Maggies Magic Muffin House opened for retail on Southern Boulevard in Boardman Ohio. 


Since then, they’ve grown by leaps & bounds providing one of the most admired, sought after and loved bakery treats in the region. 


Through many trials, tribulations & lovely gains, Maggies Magic Muffins prevails and continues to be a part of a beautiful community. They couldn’t be more happy or proud of that. 

The Magic is in the Taste.

Maggies Magic Muffins is known for having the best giant muffin selection in Ohio! From blueberry cheesecake and carrot cake muffins to peanut butter cup and pumpkin pie muffins. Stop by our Boardman OH, locations to order today!


"they are the best always fresh homemade once you have them you are hooked"

Anna Mase

"I thought I didn’t like muffins till I tried Maggie’s Magic Muffins. They are truly magical. I get a different flavor every time I go and it never disappoints!"

Danielle Leonard

"The best muffins around! I want one of each kind when I walk in. It's so hard to choose!!"

Kimberly Malatok Liller

"I haven’t tried a muffin I didn’t love; but Coconut Almond and Pistachio are my two favorites!"

Gina Dravecky

"Love their chicken salad and the muffins... well the muffins speak for themself!!! So yummy. The best hidden gem in Boardman!"

Kelly Malmfeldt Sites

Contact Me

Contact Us

Come taste the Magic! Email or Call in your basket orders today!

Thanks for submitting!

  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon

7932 Southern Blvd, Boardman, OH 44512

 ​​Tel: 330-965-7400

bottom of page